Reviews · critics and players

Mixtape reviews and scores

Critics rate Mixtape highly: an overall Metascore of 86 and an OpenCritic average of 85 with 85% of 126 critics recommending it. Individual scores range from IGN's 10/10 to PC Gamer's 74/100. On Steam, 85% of English-language user reviews are positive.

Last checked

86
Metascore
85
OpenCritic
85%
Critics recommend
85%
Steam positive

Every review score we track

The table pulls each outlet's score from its review as aggregated by OpenCritic and Wikipedia. Click Score to sort. Quotes are short excerpts from the outlet's own verdict.

Mixtape reviews and scores — full table (sortable)
Metacritic (all platforms) 86 /100All2026-11-20Overall Metascore 86. Platform tabs: PC 87, PS5 86, Xbox Series X|S 92, Switch 2 81. Outlet page
OpenCritic 85 /100All2026-11-20126 critics; 85% recommend; 'Mighty'; 80 player rating. Outlet page
IGN 10 /10PC/console2026-05-07"A musical delight from start to finish... sets a new standard for coming-of-age stories in video games." Outlet page
PC Gamer 74 /100PC2026-05-12"Lovely, beautiful, heartwarming, and unable to convince me it needed my input as a player at all." Outlet page
Game Informer 9 /10—2026-05"An incredible atmosphere... makes me nostalgic for a life I never lived." Outlet page
GameSpot 9 /10—2026-05"Music can make us feel incredibly powerful or cathartically vulnerable." Outlet page
GamesRadar+ 4 /5—2026-05"The vibes are immaculate here." Outlet page
Nintendo Life 9 /10Switch 22026-05-07Reviewer reported no performance issues; handheld visuals murkier but enjoyable. Outlet page
The Guardian 3 /5—2026-05Found it lower-stakes than Life is Strange (as summarised on Wikipedia). Outlet page
Video Games Chronicle 5 /5—2026-05— Outlet page
IGN France 7 /10—2026-05Too linear; often lacking player interaction; more 'anecdotal' experience. Outlet page
Eurogamer 4 /5—2026-05"A celebration of teenage life that makes its point, aptly, just as a teenager would." Outlet page
Steam user reviews 85 % positiveWindows2026-11-203,859 English reviews, 85% positive; recent 158 reviews 84%; 7,653 total recommendations. Outlet page

Metacritic by platform

Metacritic shows a different score on each platform tab, because each tab only counts reviews written for that version. The Xbox tab is highest, but it rests on about ten reviews; the Switch 2 tab is lowest in this snapshot. Nintendo Life separately notes softer handheld image quality; that single review does not establish why an aggregate score differs.

Metacritic Metascore per platform (checked 2026-11-20)
PlatformMetascoreCritic reviewsStatus
All platforms86Varies by snapshot1 source (Metacritic)
PC87361 source (Metacritic)
PlayStation 586411 source (Metacritic)
Xbox Series X|S92101 source (Metacritic)
Nintendo Switch 281111 source (Metacritic)

Why critics and players disagree

Reviews praise the performances, the hand-animated look and the soundtrack. The criticism is about interactivity: PC Gamer called it 'unable to convince me it needed my input as a player at all', and IGN France scored it 7/10 for the same reason. Players who wanted a game with more agency say the same in Steam reviews.

The split is not between fake and real scores. Steam's 85% positive rating is close to the critic average; the debate also concerns whether a three-hour, mostly linear story deserves game-of-the-year awards. The sources do not measure how many players hold each view. That debate has its own page.

Close-up of a teen girl with a worried look in a pink bedroom
A quiet close-up moment. Official screenshot © Beethoven & Dinosaur / Annapurna Interactive.

Player ratings

  • Steam: 3,859 English reviews, 85% positive; the last 30 days show 158 reviews at 84% (20 Nov 2026).
  • PlayStation Store: 4.59 out of 5 from about 5,200 ratings.
  • OpenCritic player score: 80.
  • Metacritic user score: left out, because the page showed inconsistent values on the day we checked.

Questions people ask

What is Mixtape's Metacritic score?

The overall Metascore is 86. By platform: PC 87, PS5 86, Xbox Series X|S 92 and Switch 2 81 (20 November 2026).

What did IGN give Mixtape?

IGN gave Mixtape 10/10, calling it a musical delight from start to finish.

Is Mixtape well reviewed on Steam?

Yes. 85% of 3,859 English Steam reviews are positive as of 20 November 2026.

Why do some reviews criticise Mixtape?

Mainly for limited interactivity and short length; PC Gamer scored it 74/100 for that reason.

Keep reading

Sources